Is there any dish that more eloquently evokes French cuisine? Boeuf bourguignon is an ultimate classic, made even more famous outside of France by the 2009 film Julie and Julia, in which a young Brooklyn woman sets out to make every dish in Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking, with boeuf bourguignon as the climax — or anti-climax, when Julie burns the stew. Like Child, Julie takes the attitude, as Columbia Pictures says, that ‘with the right combination of passion, fearlessness and butter, anything is possible.’ But — allow me a contrarian moment here — boeuf bourguignon is not a complex dish, and (pace Julia Child) it is traditionally prepared without butter.
Boeuf bourguignon / Beef braised in red wine, Burgundy style
I’ve been making bourguignon for decades, using the method most common in Burgundy itself (bourguignon translates as ‘from Burgundy’) in which various cuts of stewing beef are sliced into large cubes and sautéed with bacon, onions, garlic and a bottle of red wine. No pearl onions, no mushrooms — and no butter. I often add carrot slices, as they do in the region. Far from being a major production, it is a dish that takes no more than 20 minutes to prepare, with another 3 hours of stewing time on the stove top. No need to bake it in the oven and risk seeing your succulent stew turn into a carbonized mass.
Now a little history. According to my Burgundy cookbook, Cuisine en Bourgogne de A à Z by Amicie d’Arces, boeuf bourguignon was reserved for saintly feast days in centuries past. For the simple reason that fresh meats — beef, mutton and veal — could not be preserved in the manner of pork, and were served only on special occasions in peasant familes. The author writes that on Mardi Gras, people in the Morvan region of Burgundy used a branch from the previous year’s Palm Sunday to sprinkle their farms with sauce from boeuf bourguignon to ward off snakes! Such is the power of this dish. It’s magic.
Well, that was a long time ago and now boeuf bourguignon is regularly served throughout France — one of its most popular dishes. In fact, when you go to a French butcher to buy the meat for this stew, you don’t need to specify the cuts of meat. Just ask the butcher for ‘bourguignon’ and he’ll do it for you.
There are as many ways of making boeuf bourguignon as there are French cooks. My simple recipe reaches back in time to the most basic methods — and produces spectacular results. Others take a fancier route, with many variations: flame the meat in marc de Bourgogne (Burgundy-style grappa) or cognac, add juniper berries, cloves, tomato paste, leeks, whatever. In his recipe, the late, great Burgundy chef Bernard Loiseau used mushrooms, pearl onions and butter — along with balsamic vinegar and sugar! (Loiseau committed suicide in 2003 when it was rumored that his restaurant, La Côte d’Or, would lose its three-star status — a terrible testament to the pressure of being at the pinnacle of French cuisine.)
However you choose to make your bourguignon, it is a fine cold-weather dish that becomes even better when reheated the next day, accompanied — of course! — by a great French wine. Happy cooking.
I thought if it’s just beef with Burgundy, why not try Boeuf Perigourdin? So instead of burgundy I used a decent Bergerac red from Julien de Savignac and a glass of my own home-made vin de noix. Lovely.
Sounds fabulous! And I love the touch of adding some vin de noix. But boeuf perigourdin? Nyet, my friend. Not to be a contrarian but in the view of The Everyday French Chef this dish remains boeuf bourguignon no matter which wine one uses. In the same way that when I make confit de canard it remains a Gascon dish even though I’ve prepared it in my Paris kitchen. It’s the region where the dish originated that determines its identity. Don’t you agree?
I’m always looking for simple, tasty stews, and this inspired me to make your boeuf bourguignon for a small dinner party Saturday night. I made two small changes: First, I did the initial steps the morning, then transferred everything to the crockpot/mijoteuse to simmer all day on low temp. I also added a dried shiitake and a little Thai fish sauce. It was fabulous, thanks!
Interesting! If not exactly orthodox. The Everyday French Chef suspects you may have spent some time in Japan. Call it fusion bourguignon?
What a great post, full of fascinating historical tidbits, Meg! I can’t wait to try your version of boeuf bourguignon!
And I can’t wait to try yours, from ‘Mastering the Art of French Eating’!